Connect with us

Barcelona

Is Barcelona’s Lionel Messi Overrated?

So with a blood and guts performance, Chelsea overcame the odds and hold a slight advantage going into the 2nd leg of the semi final. But why did this happen?? Barcelona have the best player in the world but could still not break down what is the Premier League’s sixth best team (currently).

This is why the pint sized maestro Messi would not be as successful in the English Premier League.

Chelsea obviously went into the game with a certain game plan which showed with the possession stats and shots at goal but did they have a plan to stop Messi? With so many other world class players within the Barcelona team can a side go out to stop an individual when the collective will just as easily run riot.

With John Terry and Gary Cahill having exceptional games and putting in some superb blocks, the whole of the Chelsea team were organised and efficient, which showed that with a more physical game plan and organisation Barcelona can be stopped and so can Messi.

If Messi were ever to come and play in the English premier league there is no doubt he would be a great assest but would he deliver like he does in La Liga and would he be playing 50+ games a season with the premierships brutal and long fixture list.

His current statistics are played 53 games, scored 63 goals with 25 assists.

My argument is that with players like Ryan Shawcross, Vincent Kompany etc taking chunks out of him every week if not twice a week he would not be able to last the whole season therefore making his chances of having a successful season like this one very difficult.

Is it too easy in La Liga? Cristiano Ronaldo proved himself in the Premiership and is now keeping up with Messi’s great season in La Liga, does this mean that Ronaldo is more of a complete player because he has proved his ability in two different styles of football, for me it does.

What is your view? Could Lionel Messi work his magic in the English Premier League?

(Visited 2,573 times, 1 visits today)
41 Comments

41 Comments

  1. chalkontheboots

    19 April, 2012 at 21:02

    My argument is that with players like Ryan Shawcross, Vincent Kompany etc taking chunks out of him every week if not twice a week he would not be able to last the whole season therefore making his chances of having a successful season like this one very difficult.

    So what you are suggesting is that players would just boot Messi around and referee’s would permit this? He is so good, tey would resort to illegal means to prevent him being successful?

    Examine all of the chances which Barcelona created last night and then see how many Messi was involved in.

    Only the Sanchez shot off the bar did not have any involvement from Messi.

    This whole “Could Messi play in the Premiership” debate is farcical.

  2. Anonymous

    19 April, 2012 at 21:19

    This whole argument is stupid. Barca were a crossbar away, a mis-hit away and a few other goal scoring chances away from this article being titled “barca are amazing etc etc” and no one focusing on Messi’s performance. If any of those chances had fallen to Messi, he would have at least scored one of them. Chelsea gave no barca players any space whatsoever outside the box and did a very good job of it.

  3. Angelbuchi

    19 April, 2012 at 21:38

    Pls u pple shuld live messi alone to do wat God destined him 2do, any club he plays anytim he wil do wel. If u don’t appriciate dat guy believe me ur enemy of progress. If u do gud dey wil talk if u do bad dey wil stil talk

  4. Anonymous

    19 April, 2012 at 21:51

    A footballing brain always adapts. Enjoy!

  5. Roger Sanchez

    19 April, 2012 at 21:54

    Score 4 against Arsenal, 2 against ManU in 2 different finals. Now you tell me if he can play in the EPL???

  6. Anonymous

    19 April, 2012 at 21:58

    This article is a joke!!! mentioning Shawcross made me laugh!!!

  7. Anonymous

    19 April, 2012 at 21:59

    What idiot wrote this?? This is written out of pure jealousy!!!

  8. Anonymous

    19 April, 2012 at 22:02

    Player of Messi’s quality would perform anywhere. I don’t know why everybody keeps thinking that premiership is the best league in the world. This year there are 2 spanish teams in she CL semi and 3 spanish teams in Europa League semi!!!

  9. Anonymous

    19 April, 2012 at 22:10

    messi is a gud player but he never does well during his national team games for his country..at barca the whole game is being played around him that why he does so well?

  10. Leo

    19 April, 2012 at 22:13

    Another one of those stupid english articles written before their team is knocked off! Same old foolishness since 1966. How can a sane person judge Messi on a single match which chelsea needed more luck than tenacity to win. If ronaldo could get 42, why wouldnt Messi? He doesnt score in every game in laliga, but you dont get such brainless articles being published in spain. He has scored 8 goals in 6 matches agains man u and arsenal you stupid idiot. By the way, those two teams are miles ahead of Chelsea. Osasuna, getafe and chelsea have one thing in common: all got lucky against Barca, happens only once in a long time so forget about tuesday, chelsea will be ripped ti little shreds, all in the first half!!!

  11. Leo

    19 April, 2012 at 22:17

    The soone English idiots like you realise that EPL is a lesser league, the less of this brainless drivel we will get. To think you are probably paid to write this rubbish. What a waste of space.

  12. Anonymous

    19 April, 2012 at 22:19

    so many experts have realized that if the ball isnt played around messi you wont get to see the best come out from him..thats how it is with anyplayer..give them the ball more often and they will score..eg. christiano ronaldo and fernando torres when he was playing for liverpool

  13. Anonymous

    19 April, 2012 at 22:29

    messi lacks speed..he is very quick and skillful but lack speed thats why pele rated neymar much better than messi..becoz his skilful and has great speed..he creates and scores.

  14. Shola

    19 April, 2012 at 22:30

    Epl is the easiest league to play on..look at david silva always dribbles all defenders..mata does same or bern arfa see what he did i mean his last goal..so shut up

  15. Anonymous

    19 April, 2012 at 22:38

    close down the space on messi..then he wont score..thats how english teams play..tough play..messi cant handle tough play..he would never survive in the english league..there is to much runing and tight marking..CHELSEA WILL FINNISH BARCA ONCE AND FOR ALL..ITS ALL IN A MATTER OF TIME…CHELSEA CHELSEA!!!!!

  16. Roger Sanchez

    19 April, 2012 at 22:58

    @Anonymous, you talk a lot of nonsense, just look at Aguero, Silva, Mata, and Torres, all played in Spain and all are thriving(Maybe not Torres since his injury) in the EPL. Messi would score just as many goals, or probably more, being that the EPL lacks technic and skills. He would terrorise every club in the EPL, and just like he gets a kicking in La Liga, but still continual to be the phenomenon he is, same will applied in the EPL. Used your head, You don’t become Ballon d’Or 3 times on the trot if you’re overrated. Overrated applied to the Rooney’s and Beckham of this world, not to Messi.

  17. daviddoy

    19 April, 2012 at 23:37

    Messi is gud! Fine, C. Ronaldo is gud!
    Barca has d qualities bt depend much on messi dats y messi make suces. Ronaldo make name 4rm epl 2 la liga,stil gud nw,in my case,messi wil do wel in epl,bt consida dat team;liverpool or man u nt chelsea or arsenal cos dos teams neva depend on one player nd wil nt find a player on d pitcg…messi ll b average in epl:-@

  18. jj

    20 April, 2012 at 00:12

    With the retarded defenders and ridiculously bad goalkeepers, Messi would even do better in England than in Spain. Ask Silva, Aguero, Mata or Torres. They also couldn’t do it in England, right?

  19. tony montana

    20 April, 2012 at 02:46

    For those saying if we didn’t have Messi on our team, we would have bought other players to score goals and we would have been almost as good.

    This is such a ignorant point to make. This would have been true if Messi was there just to score goals for us, but he isn’t. If Messi was not around, we would not only need to replace him with another great striker, but we would need to change the way we play. Who can say our possesion football would have been as good without Messi? We play possesion football, even our 10 years old team plays exact same way, even Arsenal in some sense play in similar way. But what makes Barcelona so much better than anyone? Because we have Messi. How many times have you seen us struggle to score even though we have 70% possesion or more? This is exactly the point some people seems to be missing. Messi just don’t score goals in Barca, he makes our possesion football effective. We could buy another top quality striker in Messi’s absence but team bunkering against us will have a lot more easier task to deal with us. Hell, even if we swap Ronaldo( supposed 2nd best player in the world for many) for Messi, we would struggle to win as many games. Messi don’t only scores but his dribbling abilities and his passing makes it possible for us to unsettle opposition and it makes us easier to break these teams down. Without Messi, the team needs to play different game than we do today and this will ask for different players in midfield, attack and defence. Which could result in several of our best players being ineffective in their new role.

    2) For people who say ” But Spain win the World cup and Euro without Messi”

    Well, yes they did. But do you guys seriously think that the countries play as good football as club sides? How many countries are there who can beat Barcelona, Real Madrid, Manchester United, Valencia, Bayern Munich, Arsenal, Manchester city, Chelsea…….. even Levante or Espanyol? CLub teams play more as a team and are better overall and thus hard to beat than National teams. Therefore, you can’t say a team winning the World cup or Euros will win the league or CL.

    Other thing is that, Spain in World cup showed just how important Messi is to Barca. Sure they won World cup, but they were never as dominating as Barca. They were very close to loose to Chile, lost to Switzerland and won the Netherlands on extra time. That’s 3 of the 7 games where Spain were troubled a lot. People who says Barca players won the Euro should however consider looking at the line up of that Spain team as there were not many Barca startes on that team.

  20. magico

    20 April, 2012 at 02:49

    if messi played with real madrid he would score more than 70 goals

    ronaldo is overrated & selfish

    btw, messi won WC U20 in 2005 & golden medal in 2008 with argentina

    fake ronaldo with portugal ??? zeroooooo

    messi would rape every english team if he went to england easily

  21. Anonymous

    20 April, 2012 at 06:20

    Why are you crucifying the writer of the article.Anytime an article doesn’t toe some people’s line they attack the writer. People in this category need to learn to be tolerant and imbibe the spirit of sportmanship.The question is simple,can he survive in a physically demanding league like premiership? I doubt if he can.Can Messi even perform without xavi and iniesta? Players are used to running in England and that’s one of the areas of strenght of messi. He ‘s played 3 games against chelsea without a single goal.Messi is good no doubt about that but can’t imagine a footballer of the year without a single goal in a world cup? Do you remember Maradona, Pele,zidan,Kaka,Ronaldo,figo’s performances for both clubs and countries? As for me,Ronaldo is better than Messi anytime anyday.Messi has fifa to thank for many favour shown to him on many ocassion.

  22. Leo

    20 April, 2012 at 07:41

    At anonymous above: Which favours has fifa shown to Messi? Just about the most stupid statement i will probably hear all day. Its no surprise you are anonymous, your brain must be equally anonymous, stuck up somewhere up your behind.

  23. Nedum

    20 April, 2012 at 08:56

    Messi is jst messi nd not cr7 or any other person. He is talented nd that’s why he can play even while sleeping.

  24. Oyekanmi Henry

    20 April, 2012 at 16:24

    “The skill of monkey is great but only in the bush”. It’s people around messi that made him look greater, let him try another league like cr7 and see what happen.

  25. KOBE

    20 April, 2012 at 17:38

    its funny realy when some1 so stupid to judge messi because he never score against chelsea LOL

    and its funny when some1 so stupid too to mention ( kaka, zidane , ronaldo & figo ) in a way to say they plaed beeter for countrey & club

    messi first of all better than all of them & for the record zidane played for the best french team ever & ronaldo played for the big 4 ( barca, real ,milan & inter ) and he won the league only 1 time !!!!! & never reach the CL final ever

    WC is overrated & thats why we saw a player like klose got 13 goals overall

    . Paolo Maldini – “In my opinion, Messi should win the Golden Ball each year. He’s an unbelievable player.”

    BTW, did fake ronaldo score a super hatrick against arsenal ??^_^

  26. baggio

    20 April, 2012 at 17:40

    Oyekanmi Henry what a monkey u r LOL

    just take a look at messi’s classic vs real madrid in CL then tell us who helped messi to score it , sucker

  27. Sanchez Lujan

    20 April, 2012 at 23:26

    who do want to grom a player 4 another club to benefit, let that english club that can afford Messi try making a bid n barca would calculate all we’ve spent on him since he was a kid n see if a league like d epl can afford him. Rem’ber dat cr7 had a dream to play in madrid dats y he left n moreover madrid is a bigger club than united, tell me which epl team is bigger than Barca? How many world best players has d epl produced? Just 1

  28. sibo gama

    23 April, 2012 at 00:55

    Messi is good, really good! But if I had a team and were to choose who to have in my team between the two…Ronaldo would make my team.

    I just appreciate ronaldo’s game type and efforts when playing.

  29. frostybob7124

    24 April, 2012 at 09:33

    Although Messi is a exeptional player i do believe that the la leagua is to weak but would it be so much better for fans and Messi for more of a challenge.

    But Messi is still a amazing player and always will be

  30. LaPulga

    25 April, 2012 at 02:38

    Yet more deluded English superiority from a deluded English supremacist. Messi cant play in English that’s why year on year he CRUSHES Man Utd, Arsenal.

    EPL is better than La liga, that’s why 5 of the 8 teams in the semis of the Euro competitions are Spanish and only one English team( a COWARDLY Chelsea team that has to wear a nappy in order to cross their half way line ). Can we also mention mid table Bilbao CRUSHING table topping Man Utd with ease home and away.

    The writer of this piece almost inevitably was saying 2 years ago that Rooney( quite possibly the most overrated player in world football, since David Beckham) was better than Messi and Rio Ferdinand is the best defender in the world and Wilshere (who?) is better than Xavi and all that NONSENSE.

    The fact that Chelsea had to time waste constantly, play with 10 defenders and dive and stay on the ground at every opportunity will be seen as ‘clever tactics’ by the English media. Yet the hypocrites call overseas teams ‘cheating foreigners’ when they use it against their English teams. Bring on the Euros for England to embarrass themselves once again and we can keep idiots like this from writing this crap.

  31. Anonymous

    25 April, 2012 at 07:47

    ‘Clever tactics’ to The dumb Englishman = 10 men behind the ball. Football is becoming a disgusting game Ecuador of teams like Chelsea and Inter. Idiots In the press calling Di Matteo a mastermind when all he did was tell 10 players to park the bus inside their own 18 yard box. Hardly Guardiola or Mourinho is he?

  32. Anonymous

    25 April, 2012 at 07:47

    Ecuador was mistyped its supposed to be because

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Posts

Categories

More Football Sites

More in Barcelona