Connect with us

Manchester City

Review – Man City ‘v’ Man Utd

Result: Man City 0-1 Man Utd

19mins: Shaun Wright Phillips runs at United defence – gets fouled by Darren Fletcher – no booking

33mins: Shaun Wright Phillips runs at United defence – gets fouled by Darren Fletcher – booking

40mins: Shaun Wright Phillips runs at United defence – gets fouled by Dimitar Berbatov – no booking

53mins: Shaun Wright Phillips runs at United defence – gets fouled by Dimitar Berbatov – no booking

59mins:  Shaun Wright Phillips runs at United defence – gets fouled by Cristiano Ronaldo – booking

65mins: Shaun Wright Phillips runs at United defence – gets fouled by Patrice Evra – booking

75mins: Shaun Wright Phillips runs at United defence – gets fouled by Patrice Evra – no booking

85mins: Shaun Wright Phillips runs at United defence – gets fouled by Michael Carrick – booking

Before the start of the match, United boss Sir Alex Ferguson had complained about the treatment being received by winger Cristiano Ronaldo. He claimed that teams in previous matches had specifically targeted Ronaldo and had tried to kick him out of the game. He wanted referees to be stronger and start to book all the players who committed these fouls. Well today, at the City of Manchester Stadium, never has a point been turned on its head as much as this. As displayed above, on countless occasions the United team brought down City winger Shaun Wright-Phillips as he attempted to attack for the Blues. Time after time, Wright-Phillips would use his pace, touch and low centre of gravity to squirm his way past United players, only to be purposely fouled by these opponents. The unfortunate City winger could barely stand on his own two feet at the end of the game, such was the punishment he received. It should be noted, however, that Wright-Phillips did not roll about on the floor and demand a free-kick every time he was fouled, as would have been the case if it was Ronaldo who had been on the receiving end.

City boss and former United striker Mark Hughes made one change to the side that had so comfortably beaten Schalke in the previous match, with Brazilian star Robinho recalled in place of Danny Sturridge. United manager Ferguson made five changes from the side that faced Villareal, including recalls for Edwin Van Der Sar and Serbian defender Nemanja Vidic.

Patrice Evra competes with Darius Vassell

United started much the stronger of the two sides, and dominated the early exchanges. Scouser Wayne Rooney saw his shot partially saved by Joe Hart in the city net, Bulgarian striker Dimitar Berbatov had his glancing header tipped round the post by the City ‘keeper, and French full-back Patrice Evra smashed an effort over the bar. The only attack the home side managed in the first-half culminated in a snap-shot by Irish midfielder Stephen Ireland grazing the outside of the post. United finally took a much-deserved lead in the 42nd minute, when Rooney pounced from three yards after Hart had saved from Michael Carrick.

Wayne Rooney wheels away in delgiht after scoring for United

Mark Hughes made two changes at half time, with Pablo Zabaleta, deemed fit enough only for the bench, and Elano replacing Didi Hamann and Darius Vassell. This was the perfect chance for Elano to show Hughes of his qualities after recently criticising the manager for being left out.

City were much improved after the break and created a couple of half chances, notaby when Zimbabwean striker Benjani saw his shot hit the side netting and Belgian midfielder Vincent Kompany smashed a shot just wide. Spanish defender Javier Garrido also saw his speculative 30 yard free kick narrowly miss the post, with Edwin Van Der Sar stranded.

Then on 68 minutes, United’s Portuguese midfielder Ronaldo blatantly handled a Rooney corner after mistiming his jump, leaving referee Howard Webb with no choice put to send the winger off. Ronaldo’s sending off was warmly greeted by the home supporters, who started a chorus of ‘Cheerio’.

Cristiano Ronaldo was shown a second yellow card for an inexplicable handball

City now had a chance to level the game, but depsite seeing a vast majority of the ball, they were unable to break down a resolute United back-line. Richard Dunne saw his effort brilliantly cleared off the line by Evra and then, after a City corner was cleared in injury time, with ‘keeper Joe Hart upfield, Wayne Rooney ran half the length of the field and attempted a speculative 50 yard lob, only to see Hart sprinting back and somehow managing to claw the ball away under his goal.

Overall, City, in my opinion, didn’t deserve a point. They were completely outplayed in the first half and then lacked the imagination and creativity needed to force an equaliser.


Hart – Made a couple of decent saves, including one from Rooney’s lob at the end, and not at fault for the goal – 7

Richards – Handled Ronaldo well, but failed to get forward as much as he could have done – 6

Kompany – Very impressive in the centre of defence and moved forward into midfield with ease – 7

Dunne – Solid at the back, and made a couple of timely tackles. Nearly scored at the end – 7

Garrido – One of City’s most improved players this season. Defended well and supplied width on the left – 7

Hamann – Failed to get a foot in the game in the first-half and was replaced at the break – 5

Ireland – Didn’t look fully fit and failed to bomb forward as he has done in previous games – 6

Wright-Phillips – Best player for the home side by a country mile. Ran the midfield in the second-half, but was fouled every time he attacked – 8

Vassell – Not in the game first-half, and taken off – 5

Robinho – Another one who didn’t look fit. Unimpressive and need more from him in games like this – 5

Benjani – Failed to hold up the ball, and didn’t cause Ferdinand and Vidic too many problems – 5


Zabaleta – Imorved the balance of the team. Got stuck in and came forward well – 7

Elano – Saw lots of the ball in second-half, but passing was poor. Needs to improve – 6

Sturridge – Came on towards the end and didn’t make an impact – 6

Man of the Match: Shaun Wright-Phillips



You must be logged in to post a comment Login

Leave a Reply

More in Manchester City